INFO |
Apatosaurus
= Brontosaurus (Marsh,1879) Elosaurus
(Peterson
& Gilmore,1902) Apatosaurus
> A.ajax
= Atlantosaurus
ajax (Marsh,1877 -
Steel,1970) =
Brontosaurus
ajax (Marsh,1877 -
Bakker,1986) =
Atlantosaurus
laticollis (Marsh,1879 -
Steel,1970) =
Atlantosaurus
excelsus (Marsh,1879 -
Steel,1970) =
Camarasaurus
excelsus (Marsh,1879 -
Osborn
vide von
Huene,1929) =
Apatosaurus
amplus (Marsh,1881 -
Gilmore,1936) =
Atlantosaurus
amplus (Marsh,1881 -
Steel,1970)
A.ajax
(Marsh,1877)
>> A.
laticollis (Marsh,1879) Atlantosaurus
immanis (Marsh,1878) Apatosaurus
> A.excelsus
(Marsh,1879)
>> Brontosaurus
excelsus (Marsh,1879)
>>> Brontosaurus
amplus (Marsh,1881) Elosaurus
parvus (Peterson
& Gilmore,1902) Apatosaurus
> A.louisae
(Holland,1915) =
Atlantosaurus
louisae (Holland,1915 -
Steel,1970) =
Brontosaurus
louisae (Holland,1915 -
Bakker,
1986)
"thunder lizard" Named for its great size and powerful build
("one of the largest reptiles yet discovered"), similar in meaning
to Marsh's earlier mammal name Brontotherium "thunder beast" (1873).
Brontes was also the name of a giant in Greek mythology. Contrary to
a common explanation for the name, Marsh did not indicate that his
"thunder lizard" was supposed to make a sound like thunder when it
walked.
He recognized that his Apatosaurus and Brontosaurus were
closely related taxa, but distinguished the two forms primarily
based on the number of fused vertebrae in the sacrum of the type
specimens (three in Apatosaurus ajax, five in Brontosaurus
excelsus), a feature now known to reflect the age of individuals.
Elmer Riggs could not find sufficient grounds for treating both as
separate genera, and made the well-known name Brontosaurus a junior
synonyn of Apatosaurus in 1903.
Surprisingly, though, Riggs also thought that the type
species itself could not be identified in an adult form:
"Apatosaurus ajax is based upon a specimen too young to admit of
specific determination"--a situation, which, arguably, could have
been grounds for treating the name Apatosaurus as a nomen dubium and
using Brontosaurus instead.
Modern authorities consider Apatosaurus ajax diagnosable,
however. The nomenclatural issues surrounding the name are unrelated
to Marsh's mistaken choice of a Camarasaurus skull for his
reconstruction of "Brontosaurus." |